Three of the four domestic systemic banks (Alpha, Eurobank, Piraeus) will end the year with a higher NPE ratio than at 30 September, as a result of automatic rules and procedures that must be followed for remaining step-up and Swiss franc loans.
Under supervisory requirements that have been known for two years, step-up loans that have not been converted by 31 December to a principal-and-interest repayment structure will automatically be classified as non-performing exposures (NPEs), despite being serviced normally.
At the same time, banks are being asked to assess the future repayment capacity of borrowers with remaining Swiss franc loans, based on updated financial information and stricter supervisory requirements.
Where financial difficulties are identified, the loan will also be classified as an NPE as doubtful for collection, even though it is being serviced. Eurobank has already begun a new assessment, while Piraeus and Alpha (which has limited exposure to Swiss franc loans) are also required to do so by the end of the year.
The dilemma: hold or sell
Once the current quarter is over, the banks will know internally how much NPEs have increased as a result of the combination of factors outlined above. If, as seems likely, the rise is substantial, they will face a dilemma: “Do we burn through existing provisions and forgo interest income to sell performing loans, or keep them on the balance sheet and weigh on the NPE ratio?”.
Eurobank has indicated that it is opting for the first approach, although reports say it is reconsidering its decision. Alpha said at its recent presentation of its three-year business plan that it would retain the loans, without clarifying whether this applied to loans it had converted and classified as forborne, or to new NPEs resulting from non-conversion or financial difficulties.
Lost interest income and provisions
Both options have drawbacks and advantages. A sale would entail lost interest income, the depletion of accumulated provisions and possibly some one-off losses, as well as complaints from borrowers. All this would happen during an election period, when the government would not want to add another source of discontent, as performing borrowers would be notified that their loans were being placed in portfolios earmarked for sale.
On the other hand, maintaining asset quality could prove critical during a risk-off period, or even more so if international concerns about credit risk emerge. Retaining the loans carries the risk of additional supervisory provisions and the “hassle” of regular reassessments of borrowers’ future repayment capacity. But the bank would not forgo net interest income and would have scope to “build”/maintain its coverage ratio.
The banks estimate that around 70% of borrowers on a programme of reduced but gradually increasing instalments will accept conversion to principal-and-interest repayments. They have been setting aside corresponding provisions since last year.
In other words, they have budgeted for around 30% of step-up borrowers to reject the proposed conversion and be classified as non-performing exposures (NPEs) on 31 December 2026, even though they continue to make their reduced instalments as normal.
Confusion over newly restructured loans
This pool of NPEs should not be confused with loans classified as restructured after being converted from step-up arrangements to principal-and-interest repayments, or after borrowers used the government scheme to convert Swiss franc loans into euros. Because the terms of the loan agreements have changed, the old loans are derecognised and new loan agreements are recognised.
Where the NPV loss calculated by a bank for the orderly repayment of a debt exceeds 1%, the loans are classified as forborne and must remain under monitoring for at least two years (one year of regular servicing with principal repayment) before being transferred from Stage III to Stage II. By 30 September, a notable volume of new forborne loans, as well as new forborne impaired loans (POCI), had been recorded.
Given the confusion and the market’s underestimation of the issue, as often happens during prolonged periods of rising valuations, whichever option is chosen will need to be communicated thoroughly to investors.