Coca-Cola HBC: Eurobank Equities downgrades to Hold on Russia risk

Brokerage cuts cuts its price target after removing Russia entirely from its valuation and drops the stock from its top picks. The risks surrounding the Russian subsidiary and the potential upside.

Coca-Cola HBC: Eurobank Equities downgrades to Hold on Russia risk
O CEO της Coca Cola HBC κ. Ζόραν Μπογκντάνοβιτς

This article is an AI translation of an original piece published in Greek. Read original

Eurobank Equities has downgraded its recommendation on Coca-Cola HBC to Hold from Buy, cutting its price target to €52 from €61.70 and removing Russia entirely from its valuation model because of the high risks to the group’s control of its subsidiaries.

The reassessment follows a report recently published by Russian newspaper Kommersant, which said that brewer Bochkari had asked President Vladimir Putin to place the group’s Russian subsidiaries, Multon and Multon Partners, under external administration, with Bochkari acting as temporary administrator. The report said the request had received some government support.

The Kremlin later said it had no knowledge of such a request, while spokesman Dmitry Peskov declined to comment on internal or official correspondence. According to the brokerage, this does not confirm that the proposal is being considered at presidential level, but nor does it amount to an official rejection.

The brokerage cites the case of Carlsberg, whose Russian business was placed under temporary administration in 2023 before being sold in late 2024, saying the precedent highlights the risks to control and asset value.

Russia’s contribution

The contribution of the Russian business to the group’s profitability is particularly significant. The brokerage estimates that Russia accounts for about 15% of sales volumes, but 20%-25% of operating profit (EBIT), before the contribution from CCBA.

Its contribution to free cash flow to equity (Equity FCF) is even greater, as the portfolio relies mainly on local brands, with limited purchases of concentrates, while interest income on accumulated cash also plays a significant role. The cash balance stands at about €1bn, but is subject to repatriation restrictions.

Kommersant cited an indicative valuation by INFOLine-Analytics of the Russian businesses at 245bn roubles, or about €2.7bn. Of this amount, 150bn roubles relates to the business and 95bn roubles to cash. The valuation is below the roughly €3.5bn previously assigned by the brokerage using a discounted cash flow (DCF) model.

Cost of a potential exit

Beyond the risk of external administration, the brokerage also focuses on the particularly strict framework Russia has established for investors from countries it considers unfriendly to exit the country.

Rules tightened in October 2024 require a minimum discount of 60% to an independent valuation of market value, as well as a contribution of at least 35% of that same, undiscounted valuation to the state budget. Depending on the terms of the agreement, the contribution may be borne by either the buyer or the seller.

Based on the indicative valuation of €2.7bn, the sale price could be reduced to about €1.1bn, while the contribution to the state budget would amount to roughly €900m. Depending on who bears this cost, the group’s net proceeds could, in theory, range from just €130m to €1.1bn.

This translates into a value of €0.4 to €2.9 per share, before any adjustments for the ownership stake and transfer restrictions. The brokerage stresses that these are indicative scenarios, as the valuation is not an official assessment by the Russian authorities. A potential seizure without compensation would have clearly more adverse consequences.

Recommendation change

The brokerage estimates that the Russian business contributes about €250m a year to free cash flow to equity. However, it notes that the loss of more than €2.5bn in market capitalisation following the relevant news appears to have already priced in little or no value for Russia.

Even so, uncertainty over the intentions of the Russian authorities and the amount of any potential compensation continues to sustain an elevated geopolitical risk premium, limiting the stock’s upside.

After removing Russia from its valuation, the brokerage sets a new price target of €52 and a Hold recommendation, while dropping the stock from its top investment picks.

On its estimates, the stock trades at 11.5 times 2027 estimated enterprise value to EBITDA and 21.4 times estimated earnings (P/E), excluding Russia and including CCBA. These multiples imply a premium of more than 20% to the sector average.

The brokerage continues to recognise the strong growth prospects of the company’s core business. However, it believes that the combination of limited upside to the new price target, a demanding valuation relative to the sector and geopolitical uncertainty is likely to keep the stock in a narrow trading range in the coming period.

v
Privacy