A “crack” in securitisations of non-performing loans is widening, leaving servicers facing court rulings — many on appeal — that block seizures and auctions. The summaries of loan transfer agreements that servicers submit to courts omit a detail the judiciary considers essential to establishing their legal standing: the price paid by the credit purchaser (fund) to the bank for the loan.
In recent months, borrowers’ legal arguments have found a receptive audience in the country’s courts of appeal. Two notable appeal rulings show how this legal gap is “freezing” enforcement proceedings:
- Larissa Single-Member Court of Appeal (Decision 492/2026): The court suspended the auction of commercial properties owned by a general partnership in Volos. The properties had been seized over a debt arising from a 2001 loan. The court found that omitting the sale price from the registered summaries of the securitisation agreements at the Pledge Registry raised serious questions about the validity of the transfer. It held that the sale price must be stated, at least in summary form, in the registered summary, and that merely referring to the full contract is not enough. If the transfer to the foreign special-purpose vehicle (SPV) did not take legal effect, the servicing company (servicer) has no standing to pursue the claim.
- Patras Single-Member Court of Appeal (Decision 185/2025): In a similar case, the court annulled the enforcement proceedings in their entirety — the demand for payment, the seizure and the extract of seizure — over a loan of about €280,000. The ruling explicitly states that a sale agreement which does not specify the purchase price, but merely refers to other documents that were neither filed nor served, is “incomplete”. As a result, it does not transfer ownership of the claim, leaving the servicer with no right to pursue enforcement action.
First-instance courts have taken a similar approach in recent years (Heraklion Single-Member Court of First Instance 825/2025, Athens Single-Member Court of First Instance 13/2025).
A contrary ruling in Piraeus
Lawyers point out, however, that the case law has yet to settle on a clear direction. For example, in a recent ruling (181/2026), the Piraeus Court of Appeal rejected an application to suspend an auction.
According to the reasoning in the ruling, whether the transfer and servicing price is stated is irrelevant to the standing of the respondent — in this case, the servicer.
The court held that it was sufficient for the duly registered extracts of the agreements at the Pledge Registry under Law 3156/2003 to be served together. Those extracts specify the claim being transferred, its nature, the parties liable and the security interests (mortgage prenotation). There is no need to serve or register the entire agreement, or to state the purchase price expressly, for the servicer to have standing to continue enforcement proceedings.
Servicers have consistently argued that, in securitisations, there was no need to state the transfer price for each individual loan, only the total amounts. Moreover, as court rulings have also accepted, the transfer price of a loan does not alter the amount owed by the borrower.
The gap in the legal framework
Lawyers representing borrowers consider the price to be an essential element of a loan transfer agreement. They argue that the law requires the “essential elements” of a claim to be registered for it to be transferred — and that the price is an essential element of a transfer.
Servicers, however, rely on a Joint Ministerial Decision (JMD 19169/2024), which sets out the standard forms for publication at the Pledge Registry. It covers agreements transferring claims (the sale of loans by banks to funds) and servicing agreements (the appointment of servicers), as provided for in Articles 14 and 21 of Law 5072/2023.
On the question of whether the transfer price must be stated, the JMD says something particularly important: rather than requiring the exact price to be stated in the publication at the Pledge Registry, it allows the form to refer only to the relevant article of the sale agreement (for example, “the price is set out in Article 3.1 of the Agreement”).
Servicing companies therefore argue in court that they fully comply with the law when they omit the price from the summary, because they follow the format prescribed by the state under JMD 19169/2024. They also argue that the price concerns their internal relations and has no effect on the borrower, who owes the same amount regardless.
On the other hand, some courts have upheld borrowers’ arguments that a ministerial decision cannot override primary legislation.
Both the former Law 3156/2003 and the new Law 5072/2023 require the “essential elements” of a claim to be registered for it to be transferred. In law, the price is the most essential element of a sale. Accordingly, courts consider a transfer “incomplete” if the price is not stated, and the seizure invalid.
It is worth noting that the latest law, Law 5072/2023, expressly gives credit servicers special standing to bring legal claims and take court action to collect the claims they manage. It also treats service of the publication forms recorded in the register of the competent Pledge Registry as full proof of that special standing. Similar provision is made for the transfer and servicing of securitised claims.
However, the law did not expressly clarify whether the loan transfer price must also be stated in the publication form, an issue the Joint Ministerial Decision sought to address. The JMD does not appear to have settled the question of the price, which is why courts are issuing rulings in both directions.
Is legislation the only way forward?
The issue is now beginning to pose a serious, systemic problem for servicers’ seizure and auction proceedings. The growing number of rulings invalidating enforcement actions because the price was not stated threatens to derail business plans for recoveries and hold up pending cases.
Legal and financial circles believe this divergence of opinion and the resulting legal uncertainty may have to be resolved definitively through new legislation. Any new measure would need to specify exactly what must be included in the summaries of agreements registered at the Pledge Registry, clarifying whether the price must also be stated. Alternatively, the issue will continue to be litigated until it is potentially resolved by a Supreme Court ruling.