Greece and four other countries ready to send migrants to Rwanda

The plan envisages transferring people who have no legal right to remain. Talks with Kigali and human rights concerns. Legal challenges are expected.

Greece and four other countries ready to send migrants to Rwanda

This article is an AI translation of an original piece published in Greek. Read original

Five EU member states have announced plans to set up a returns centre outside Europe in Rwanda for people who have no legal right to remain in Europe. The pilot scheme is expected to face legal challenges and has been condemned as a “serious moral failure”.

The five countries —Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Denmark and Greece— are the first to seek to use new EU legislation on returns, agreed recently, which allows people who have exhausted all avenues of appeal against their removal from Europe to be sent to a third country.

In a statement released today, the five EU countries said they “will begin concrete negotiations with the partner country, Rwanda, to implement the plan”, adding that it would contribute “significantly to further curbing irregular migration, dismantling the business model of people smugglers and easing pressure on our population”.

Officials hope that 100 people will be sent to Rwanda from early next year to test the model. The programme will apply to adults whose asylum applications have been rejected, as well as others who have no legal right to reside in the EU.

In theory, according to diplomatic sources, migrants will stay for a few months at a reception centre in Rwanda and then choose either to integrate into the society of the Great Lakes country or return to their country of origin, the Guardian reports.

Unlike the failed Rwanda scheme pursued by the UK Conservative government, and Italy’s agreement with Albania, the programme will not cover people whose asylum applications are still being considered.

The five countries said the reception centre, which will be an open facility, is not intended to accommodate people long term but to handle regular flows of migrants. Diplomatic sources said the EU countries would not use the facilities built in Kigali with British funding.

The governments involved argue that the plan will protect the European asylum system, while removing the incentive for irregular migrants to enter Europe.

Denmark’s immigration minister, Morten Bødskov, whose government has led the adoption of a tough migration policy that has been widely emulated across the EU, said the plan represented “huge progress”.

German interior minister Alexander Dobrindt said: “Returns centres offer a positive approach for people who have no right to stay and no prospects in Europe, because their countries of origin are not co-operating with the repatriation process.”

Andy Burnham told reporters last week that the UK had not held direct talks with the European governments involved in plans for returns centres, but added: “We will watch developments with interest, learning lessons from what happened in the past. Public opinion wants us to do everything we can to tackle illegal migration.”

Critics have highlighted the ethical difficulties involved in reaching an agreement with Rwanda’s repressive government. In 2024, the US State Department found that the country allows state security forces and public officials to commit human rights abuses without facing sanctions, while concerns have also been raised about freedom of expression and forced labour.

French Green MEP Mélissa Camara condemned the five countries’ agreement with Rwanda as a “shameful deal” and a “serious moral failure”. She said: “Under this agreement, people will be deported thousands of miles from the European Union, with no guarantee that their rights will be respected.”

Alain Berset, secretary-general of the Council of Europe, the continent’s human rights organisation, said it was not possible “to be so specific in advance” about what any proposal to establish returns centres would entail.

Speaking to the Guardian before the announcement, he said all Council of Europe members were bound by the European Convention on Human Rights and that “this must be the guiding light” for all discussions about returns centres.

“As regards specific cases, we will have to assess whether they are compatible with the Convention,” he said. He also stressed that “all countries must be able to determine their migration policy”.

Officials involved in setting up migrant reception centres expect legal challenges, but argue that the programme is grounded in human rights law.

Rights groups believe the plan is doomed to fail. “Member states may call them ‘returns centres’ or even ‘reception centres’, but no euphemism can conceal the violence involved in uprooting people from the lives they have built in Europe and sending them to a country they may not even know, without family, support networks or meaningful prospects,” said Chiara Catelli of Picum, a pan-European organisation campaigning for the rights of undocumented migrants.

v
Privacy